Scarsdale, New York, a name synonymous with stately homes, excellent schools, and a refined suburban lifestyle, is more than just a picturesque community. It’s also a hidden gem for food enthusiasts. Beyond the manicured lawns and tree-lined streets lies a surprisingly diverse and vibrant culinary landscape, offering everything from classic comfort food to cutting-edge cuisine. This guide is your passport to navigating the best food in Scarsdale, ensuring you discover the delicious delights this Westchester County town has to offer. Whether you’re a long-time resident or a first-time visitor, prepare to embark on a gastronomic adventure.
Scarsdale has so much to offer from old school establishments to upscale contemporary fare. Let’s dive into it all!
Timeless Tastes: Scarsdale’s Classic Dining Experiences
Some restaurants become ingrained in a community’s identity, weaving themselves into the fabric of local life. Scarsdale is home to several such establishments, places where generations have celebrated milestones, shared family meals, and simply enjoyed good food and company.
Let’s start with Il Castello, a local institution that has been serving up authentic Italian cuisine for over forty years. This family-run restaurant exudes warmth and hospitality, the aromas of simmering sauces and freshly baked bread filling the air. The menu is a testament to classic Italian cooking, featuring dishes like perfectly al dente pasta carbonara, rich and creamy lasagna Bolognese, and osso buco that melts in your mouth. The secret? High-quality ingredients, time-honored recipes passed down through generations, and a dedication to providing a memorable dining experience. Il Castello is more than just a restaurant; it’s a gathering place, a symbol of Scarsdale’s enduring traditions.
Next on our list is The Scarsdale Diner, a quintessential American eatery that has been serving up breakfast, lunch, and dinner to Scarsdale residents for decades. With its retro decor, comfortable booths, and extensive menu, The Scarsdale Diner is a comforting presence, a place where you can always count on a hearty meal and a friendly face. From fluffy pancakes and crispy bacon in the morning to juicy burgers and creamy milkshakes in the afternoon, The Scarsdale Diner offers something for everyone. It’s the perfect spot for a casual family meal, a quick bite with friends, or a late-night snack. The diner is a symbol of accessibility and down-to-earth goodness in a town known for its elegance.
Finally, no discussion of classic Scarsdale food is complete without mentioning DeCicco & Sons, a gourmet market with an exceptional pizza counter. While technically a market, their pizza is a local legend. Known for its thin, crispy crust, fresh toppings, and perfectly balanced sauce, DeCicco’s pizza is a go-to for everything from family dinners to impromptu gatherings. The lines can be long, especially on weekends, but the wait is always worth it. It’s a testament to the simple pleasure of a perfectly crafted slice. DeCicco’s has several locations in Westchester County, but the Scarsdale location holds a special place in the hearts (and stomachs) of local pizza lovers.
Modern Flavors: Exploring Scarsdale’s Trendy Eateries
While Scarsdale cherishes its classic restaurants, the town is also embracing a wave of new and innovative eateries that are pushing the boundaries of culinary creativity. These modern establishments are adding a fresh and exciting dimension to Scarsdale’s food scene.
One standout is Chat American Grill, a restaurant that focuses on using local and seasonal ingredients to create dishes that are both flavorful and visually stunning. Their menu changes frequently to reflect the availability of the freshest produce, meats, and seafood. From perfectly seared scallops to braised short ribs, each dish is a work of art, showcasing the chef’s skill and passion for quality. The atmosphere is chic and sophisticated, making it a perfect spot for a special occasion or a romantic dinner. Chat American Grill is a testament to Scarsdale’s evolving culinary tastes.
Another noteworthy addition to Scarsdale’s food scene is Lange’s of Bronxville Deli. This is a sandwich shop that makes the list because their food is just that great. Each sandwich is made fresh to order. Locals rave about the quality and taste of their sandwiches
These innovative restaurants are breathing new life into Scarsdale’s food scene, offering residents and visitors a chance to experience the latest culinary trends without leaving town.
Quick Bites and Casual Eats: Scarsdale’s Everyday Options
Sometimes, you just need a quick and easy meal without sacrificing quality or flavor. Scarsdale has plenty of options for casual dining, offering everything from delicious coffee and pastries to satisfying sandwiches and salads.
For coffee lovers, Starbucks offers quick bites and great caffeine to kickstart your day. It’s a great spot to catch up with friends or get work done.
When lunchtime rolls around, Scarsdale offers a variety of options for a quick and tasty meal. Many local delis and sandwich shops offer fresh ingredients and quality sandwiches.
In addition to the brick-and-mortar restaurants mentioned, apps like Uber Eats and DoorDash offer convenient takeout options in the area.
Celebrating Moments: Fine Dining Experiences in Scarsdale
For special occasions or simply a desire for an elevated dining experience, Scarsdale offers a few fine dining restaurants that are sure to impress.
La Dentelliere is the gold standard for fine dining in the area. Serving up the finest French dishes in an intimate setting. Located on Harwood court, the restaurant is a great experience for tourists and locals alike.
Catering to All: Dietary Needs and Preferences
Scarsdale’s diverse food scene also caters to a variety of dietary needs and preferences. Whether you’re vegetarian, vegan, or gluten-free, you’ll find plenty of options to choose from.
Many of the restaurants mentioned above offer vegetarian and vegan options on their menus. For example, the fresh salads, pasta and veggie dishes at Il Castello are fan favorites for local pescatarians.
For those with gluten sensitivities or celiac disease, some restaurants offer gluten-free menus or are willing to accommodate special requests.
Many restaurants are family-friendly and offer kid’s menus to keep the little ones happy. The Scarsdale Diner, for example, is a popular spot for families, offering a relaxed atmosphere and a variety of kid-friendly options.
Local Flavor: Food Events and Markets
While Scarsdale doesn’t have a traditional farmers market within its borders, its proximity to other Westchester towns means that residents have easy access to a variety of local food events and markets. These events offer a chance to support local farmers and artisans and to sample fresh, seasonal produce.
A Culinary Oasis: Scarsdale’s Food Scene
From classic Italian cuisine to innovative farm-to-table dishes, Scarsdale offers a diverse range of food experiences to suit every taste and budget. Whether you’re looking for a casual lunch, a romantic dinner, or a quick bite on the go, you’re sure to find something to satisfy your cravings in this charming Westchester town. So, the next time you’re in Scarsdale, be sure to explore the town’s culinary landscape and discover the delicious delights that await. The food in Scarsdale is something you will be sure to remember. What are your favorite restaurants in Scarsdale? Share them in the comments below!
