Scarborough, Maine: it’s a name that conjures images of sun-drenched beaches, crashing waves, and the quintessential New England coastline. While the town’s natural beauty certainly takes center stage, a delightful culinary scene is quietly flourishing, offering a diverse range of flavors that extends far beyond the typical tourist traps. Forget the crowded beaches for a moment and prepare to embark on a culinary journey through Scarborough, where the freshest seafood meets farm-to-table innovation and a friendly, welcoming atmosphere pervades every bite. This guide will lead you through some of the very best places to eat in Scarborough, showcasing everything from classic Maine lobster shacks to innovative restaurants that are reimagining local ingredients. Whether you’re a seasoned foodie or simply seeking a memorable meal, Scarborough’s vibrant food scene is sure to tantalize your taste buds.
Seafood Sensations and Classic Maine Experiences
No trip to the Maine coast is complete without indulging in its iconic seafood. Fortunately, Scarborough boasts an abundance of options for satisfying your crustacean cravings. Lobster rolls, in particular, are a must-try, and several establishments in town are renowned for their exceptional versions of this New England staple.
When discussing lobster rolls, one simply must mention The Lobster Shack at Two Lights State Park. While technically just outside of Scarborough’s main town center (a very short drive!), this spot is a true destination. Situated on the rocky coastline, it offers breathtaking ocean views alongside their legendary lobster rolls. What makes them stand out? Perhaps it’s the generous portion of fresh, succulent lobster meat, lightly tossed with mayonnaise and served on a perfectly toasted bun. Maybe it’s the salty sea air and the sound of the waves crashing below. Whatever the secret, The Lobster Shack is a true Maine experience. Be prepared for a potential wait, especially during peak season, but the reward is well worth it.
For a more casual experience, consider Bayley’s Lobster Pound, a Scarborough institution. Here, you can watch as your lobster is freshly steamed and cracked, ready to be enjoyed at one of their picnic tables overlooking the harbor. Besides lobster rolls, Bayley’s offers a wide array of other seafood delights, including steamed clams, fried haddock, and clam chowder. It’s the perfect place to enjoy an authentic Maine seafood feast in a relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere.
The “Maine lobster roll experience” is unique for several reasons. First and foremost, it’s about the freshness of the lobster. Maine lobsters are renowned for their sweet, delicate flavor, and the best lobster rolls are made with meat that was caught that very day. Second, it’s about simplicity. The classic Maine lobster roll is not overloaded with unnecessary ingredients. It’s about showcasing the lobster’s natural flavor, letting it shine through with just a touch of mayonnaise or melted butter, and a lightly toasted roll. This minimalist approach allows the quality of the ingredients to take center stage.
Beyond the Casual: Refined Seafood Dining
While casual seafood shacks are a beloved part of the Scarborough food scene, there are also options for those seeking a more refined dining experience. Several restaurants in town offer sophisticated seafood preparations, showcasing the culinary talent of local chefs.
The Garage BBQ and Grill is located in the heart of Scarborough. The restaurant has become a local favorite. The Garage features expertly grilled seafood such as tuna, salmon, and swordfish.
Dunstan Tap & Table stands out for its elevated seafood options, utilizing locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. The ambiance is modern and stylish, making it a perfect spot for a special occasion or a romantic dinner.
These establishments showcase the versatility of Maine seafood, proving that it can be just as delightful in an elegant setting as it is in a casual lobster shack. The chefs bring creativity and skill to their dishes, highlighting the natural flavors of the ocean while adding their own unique twists.
Beyond the Sea: A Spectrum of Flavors
Scarborough’s culinary landscape extends far beyond seafood, offering a diverse array of options to satisfy every craving. A growing farm-to-table movement is taking root, with several restaurants prioritizing locally sourced ingredients and showcasing the bounty of Maine’s agricultural landscape.
The Maine Table, for example, is a champion of this approach. This restaurant works closely with local farmers and producers to create seasonal menus that highlight the freshest ingredients available. Their dishes are creative, flavorful, and beautifully presented, reflecting a deep appreciation for the land and the people who cultivate it. The menu changes regularly depending on what’s in season, so there’s always something new and exciting to try.
For those seeking casual comfort food, Scarborough has plenty to offer. Pat’s Pizza is a Scarborough mainstay, beloved for their delicious pizzas and welcoming atmosphere. Jimmy the Greeks offers some of the best Gyros in Maine. Scarborough has options for every palette.
Adding to the global flavors of the city, Amigo’s Mexican Restaurant brings authentic flavors of Mexico to Maine.
Sweet Endings and Baked Delights
No culinary adventure is complete without indulging in a sweet treat. Scarborough boasts a number of excellent ice cream shops, bakeries, and coffee shops, providing the perfect way to end a meal or simply enjoy a delightful afternoon treat.
During the summer months, Len Libby Candies is a must-visit. This iconic Maine establishment is famous for its life-sized chocolate moose and its wide selection of homemade candies and ice cream. It’s a fun and whimsical place to visit, and the ice cream is simply delicious.
For those seeking a more sophisticated dessert experience, On the Vine Marketplace offers a variety of high-quality pastries, cakes, and desserts. Their coffee is also excellent, making it a perfect spot to relax and enjoy a sweet treat with a friend.
Discovering Local Markets and Farm Stands
For a taste of the true Maine harvest, venturing to the local markets and farm stands can lead to hidden culinary gems. Buying fresh produce directly from local farmers offers a delightful way to experience the seasonality of Maine’s food scene. These markets often showcase artisanal cheeses, homemade jams, and freshly baked goods, perfect for crafting your own picnic basket to enjoy at one of Scarborough’s scenic spots.
The Scarborough Farmers Market (seasonal) is a fantastic place to find local produce, meats, cheeses, and baked goods. Check their website for schedule.
Tips for Foodies Visiting Scarborough
Planning your culinary journey to Scarborough requires a few considerations to ensure a seamless and satisfying experience. The best time to visit largely depends on your preferences. Summer months bring peak season, with warmer weather and vibrant energy, but also larger crowds and potential waits at popular restaurants. Shoulder seasons like spring and fall offer a more relaxed atmosphere, pleasant weather, and potentially lower prices.
Reservations are highly recommended at many of the finer dining establishments, especially during peak season. Calling ahead or booking online can save you valuable time and ensure you secure a table at your desired restaurant. For the more casual seafood shacks, be prepared for potential waits, especially during lunch and dinner hours.
Scarborough offers a range of dining options to suit various budgets. From affordable lobster rolls and casual fare to upscale seafood dinners, there’s something for everyone. Researching menus and prices beforehand can help you plan your meals according to your budget.
Navigating Scarborough is relatively easy. Having your own vehicle provides the most flexibility for exploring different areas of the town. Parking is generally available, although it can be limited in certain areas during peak season. Ride-sharing services are also available, providing a convenient alternative to driving.
Scarborough’s Culinary Appeal
Scarborough’s rising culinary appeal stems from a combination of factors. The town’s proximity to the ocean and its strong fishing tradition provide access to the freshest seafood. The growing farm-to-table movement is fostering a deeper connection between restaurants and local producers, resulting in dishes that showcase the unique flavors of Maine’s agricultural landscape. A talented community of chefs and restaurateurs is bringing creativity and innovation to the Scarborough food scene, pushing the boundaries of traditional New England cuisine. These factors, combined with the town’s natural beauty and welcoming atmosphere, make Scarborough an increasingly attractive destination for food lovers.
Conclusion: Savoring Scarborough
From the salty tang of a freshly shucked oyster to the sweet succulence of a Maine lobster roll, Scarborough’s food scene is a celebration of coastal flavors and local bounty. Whether you are looking for a classic seafood dinner, a casual beachside bite, or a taste of innovative farm-to-table cuisine, Scarborough, Maine has something to offer every palate. So, pack your appetite, explore the town’s hidden culinary gems, and prepare to be delighted by the diverse and delicious offerings that await. It’s time to plan your unforgettable culinary adventure in Scarborough, Maine! Let the flavors of the coast be your guide. You won’t be disappointed.
