Introduction
Suttons Bay, Michigan. Just the name conjures images of pristine beaches, sparkling turquoise waters, and that unmistakable Up North charm. But beyond the stunning natural beauty, this gem of the Leelanau Peninsula harbors a delectable secret: a burgeoning food scene that’s drawing culinary enthusiasts from far and wide. Forget the crowded tourist traps; Suttons Bay offers a slower pace, a more authentic taste of Northern Michigan, and culinary experiences you won’t find anywhere else. From upscale farm-to-table dining to comforting casual eats and award-winning wineries, Suttons Bay truly is a food lover’s paradise waiting to be explored. This guide will take you on a delicious journey through the heart of Suttons Bay, uncovering the best places to eat, drink, and savor the flavors of Leelanau County.
Elevated Dining Experiences
When you’re looking for a memorable meal, Suttons Bay delivers. Several restaurants offer sophisticated menus, impeccable service, and atmospheres that perfectly complement the breathtaking scenery.
Martha’s Leelanau Table
Consider Martha’s Leelanau Table, a celebrated restaurant that consistently earns rave reviews. With its focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients, Martha’s creates dishes that are both innovative and deeply satisfying. The ambiance is elegant yet welcoming, making it ideal for a special occasion or a romantic evening. Don’t miss the opportunity to try their pan-seared whitefish, a regional specialty prepared with seasonal vegetables and a delicate lemon-butter sauce. The chef’s passion for showcasing the best of Leelanau’s bounty shines through in every bite. Martha’s Leelanau Table offers a refined dining experience with entrees typically ranging from twenty-five to forty dollars.
9 Bean Rows Bakery & Farm Cafe
Another exceptional option is 9 Bean Rows Bakery & Farm Cafe. This establishment is not only a bakery but also a farm that provides ingredients that are used in their cafe. This ensures that the food they provide is fresh and of high quality. Their menu features fresh sandwiches, salads and baked goods. The prices range from fifteen to thirty dollars making it a good place for a casual bite.
Why These Restaurants Are Special
These establishments share a commitment to quality ingredients, creative cuisine, and a dedication to showcasing the best of what Northern Michigan has to offer. Expect exceptional service, thoughtfully curated wine lists, and an unforgettable dining experience at either location.
Casual Bites and Local Hotspots
While Suttons Bay boasts fine dining, its charm truly shines through in its more casual eateries and local favorites. These are the places where you can grab a quick bite, soak in the laid-back atmosphere, and connect with the community.
Fig’s Breakfast and Bake
For a delightful lunch or a perfectly crafted sandwich, head to Fig’s Breakfast and Bake. This cozy deli is a local institution, known for its generous portions, fresh ingredients, and friendly service. Their sandwiches are legendary, made with freshly baked bread and piled high with flavorful meats and cheeses. Be sure to try their turkey sandwich, a customer favorite known for its homemade cranberry sauce and perfectly roasted turkey. Fig’s is also a great place to grab a coffee and a pastry in the morning. Prices are incredibly reasonable, with most sandwiches costing between eight and twelve dollars.
Village Inn
If you’re craving something heartier, Village Inn is the place to be. This classic American restaurant serves up comforting classics with a local twist. Whether you’re in the mood for a juicy burger, crispy fries, or a slice of homemade pie, Village Inn has something for everyone. Don’t forget to try their signature burger, featuring locally sourced beef and topped with their special sauce. It’s a truly satisfying meal that won’t break the bank, with entrees ranging from ten to fifteen dollars.
Scoops 22
No visit to Suttons Bay is complete without indulging in a sweet treat, and Scoops 22 is the perfect place to satisfy your cravings. This charming ice cream parlor offers a wide variety of flavors, from classic vanilla and chocolate to more adventurous options like cherry pie and maple walnut. All of their ice cream is homemade and utterly delicious. Treat yourself to a scoop (or two!) and enjoy the taste of summer. A scoop of their delicious ice cream cost about three to five dollars.
Wine Country Delights and Craft Brews
Suttons Bay’s location in the heart of Leelanau County makes it a premier destination for wine lovers. Numerous wineries dot the landscape, each offering its own unique tasting experience.
Black Star Farms
Black Star Farms is a must-visit for any wine enthusiast. This stunning estate boasts a beautiful tasting room, expansive vineyards, and even an inn for those who want to extend their stay. Their wines are consistently award-winning, with a focus on cool-climate varietals like Pinot Grigio, Riesling, and Chardonnay. Be sure to try their Arcturos Pinot Grigio, a crisp and refreshing white wine that perfectly captures the essence of Leelanau County. The tasting room offers a variety of tasting flights, as well as opportunities to purchase bottles to take home. Black Star Farms also offers small plates to pair with your wine. Black Star Farms is located at 10844 E Revold Rd, Suttons Bay, MI 49682.
Shady Lane Cellars
Another standout winery is Shady Lane Cellars, a charming vineyard known for its friendly atmosphere and exceptional wines. Shady Lane Cellars offers a variety of red and white wines as well as cider. Visit them at 9580 E Shady Ln, Suttons Bay, MI 49682.
Hop Lot Brewing Company
For those who prefer hops to grapes, Hop Lot Brewing Company offers a fantastic selection of craft beers in a unique outdoor setting. Their rotating tap list features a variety of styles, from hoppy IPAs to rich stouts, and their outdoor beer garden is the perfect place to relax and enjoy a pint. They also have a menu of pub fare, including burgers, sandwiches, and appetizers.
Local Flavors and Must-Try Specialties
No visit to Suttons Bay would be complete without sampling some of the region’s most iconic foods. The area is particularly known for its cherries and whitefish.
Cherry Products
Cherries are a staple of Northern Michigan, and you’ll find them incorporated into everything from pies and jams to salsas and sauces. Stop by a local farm stand to pick up a bag of fresh cherries or a jar of homemade cherry jam. Many local restaurants also feature cherry-inspired dishes on their menus. The Cherry Hut is a great option to try cherry products.
Whitefish
Whitefish is another must-try delicacy. This flaky, mild-flavored fish is a regional specialty, and you’ll find it prepared in a variety of ways. Try it smoked, pan-fried, or grilled. Many restaurants offer whitefish as a featured item on their menu.
Tips for Your Suttons Bay Food Adventure
To make the most of your culinary exploration of Suttons Bay, here are a few helpful tips:
Best Time to Visit
The best time to visit Suttons Bay for food lovers is during the summer or fall. Summer offers warm weather and outdoor dining, while fall brings harvest festivals and stunning foliage.
Getting Around
Suttons Bay is a walkable village, but you may want to consider renting a bike or bringing your car to explore the surrounding area.
Making Reservations
Especially during peak season, it’s always a good idea to make reservations at popular restaurants.
Local Events
Keep an eye out for food festivals, wine tastings, and other culinary events.
Exploring The Area
Don’t be afraid to explore beyond the main street. Some of the best hidden gems are located just a short drive away.
Conclusion: A Taste of Paradise
Suttons Bay is more than just a pretty place; it’s a culinary destination that offers a truly unique and unforgettable experience. With its focus on fresh, local ingredients, its charming restaurants and wineries, and its welcoming community, Suttons Bay is a place where you can truly savor the flavors of Northern Michigan. So, pack your bags, grab your appetite, and prepare for a delicious adventure. Plan your culinary escape to Suttons Bay today and discover the taste of paradise. You won’t be disappointed. The friendly locals will always welcome you to their wonderful food and wine destinations. Take your time and explore the village for an experience you’ll never forget.
