Craving the vibrant flavors of Mexico but find yourself firmly planted on the Upper West Side? You’re not alone. For years, dedicated foodies have embarked on quests to find truly exceptional Mexican cuisine amidst the brownstones and cultural institutions that define this iconic neighborhood. While the Upper West Side might be better known for its bagels and brunch, a surprisingly diverse and delicious Mexican food scene is quietly flourishing, offering everything from authentic street tacos to sophisticated contemporary dishes.
The Upper West Side, with its blend of families, students, and long-time residents, has always been a culinary melting pot. Over the years, the neighborhood’s food scene has evolved, embracing new flavors and trends. While reliable delis and classic diners still hold their own, a new wave of restaurants, including a growing number of Mexican establishments, has injected fresh energy into the area.
But let’s be honest: navigating the Upper West Side’s Mexican food landscape can be tricky. Sifting through the options to find truly authentic and satisfying meals requires a discerning eye and a bit of insider knowledge. That’s where this guide comes in. We’re here to unveil the best Mexican restaurants on the Upper West Side, highlighting hidden gems, local favorites, and diverse menu options to satisfy any craving. From late-night taco runs to festive family dinners, prepare to discover your new go-to spots for a taste of Mexico, right here on the UWS. Get ready for a culinary adventure that proves the Upper West Side is more than just matzoh ball soup.
A Taste of Oaxaca on Amsterdam Avenue
Nestled on Amsterdam Avenue, you’ll find a restaurant that transports you straight to the heart of Oaxaca. The warm, inviting atmosphere, with its colorful murals and rustic decor, sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. This isn’t your typical Tex-Mex joint; expect authentic Oaxacan cuisine prepared with fresh, high-quality ingredients and a deep respect for tradition.
The tlayudas are an absolute must-try. These massive, crispy tortillas are topped with black bean puree, quesillo cheese, your choice of protein (like succulent grilled chicken or flavorful chorizo), avocado, and salsa. Each bite is an explosion of flavor and texture – a truly satisfying and shareable dish. Don’t miss the mole negro, either. This complex, slow-cooked sauce, made with dozens of ingredients including chilies, chocolate, and spices, is a true testament to Oaxacan culinary artistry. Served over chicken or enchiladas, it’s a rich, savory, and slightly sweet experience that you won’t soon forget.
Expect to pay around twenty to thirty dollars per person. What sets this restaurant apart is its dedication to showcasing the unique flavors of Oaxaca. They source many of their ingredients directly from Mexico, ensuring an authentic taste that you won’t find anywhere else on the Upper West Side. As one recent customer put it, “This is the real deal. The mole is incredible, and the tlayudas are out of this world. It’s like a trip to Oaxaca without leaving Manhattan!”
Family-Friendly Fiesta on Columbus Avenue
For a lively and family-friendly Mexican experience, head to Columbus Avenue. This vibrant restaurant boasts a festive atmosphere, complete with colorful decorations and upbeat music. It’s the perfect spot for a casual dinner with friends or a fun celebration with the whole family.
The menu offers a wide variety of classic Mexican dishes, but the fajitas are a definite standout. Sizzling platters arrive tableside, piled high with your choice of marinated steak, chicken, or shrimp, along with peppers, onions, and all the fixings. The portions are generous, and the flavors are bold and satisfying. Another crowd-pleaser is the enchiladas suizas. These cheesy, creamy enchiladas are filled with chicken and topped with a tangy tomatillo sauce. They’re the perfect comfort food on a chilly New York evening.
A meal here will likely cost between fifteen and twenty-five dollars per person. This spot is special because of its warm, welcoming atmosphere and its commitment to serving consistently delicious food at reasonable prices. They also have a fantastic kids’ menu, making it a great choice for families with young children. Their frozen margaritas are a local favorite, perfect for unwinding after a long day.
Authentic Street Tacos on Broadway
If you’re craving a quick and authentic taco fix, look no further than the unassuming gem located on Broadway. This no-frills establishment focuses on serving up delicious street tacos made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Don’t expect fancy decor or elaborate presentations – the focus here is purely on the food.
The carne asada tacos are a must-try. The grilled steak is tender and flavorful, seasoned perfectly with a blend of spices. Topped with onions, cilantro, and a squeeze of lime, they’re a simple yet satisfying treat. The al pastor tacos are also excellent. The marinated pork is cooked on a vertical spit and shaved into small, flavorful pieces. They’re slightly sweet and savory, with a hint of pineapple.
These delicious tacos are very affordable, expect to pay under ten dollars for a satisfying meal. The location is special because of its commitment to authentic flavors and its incredibly reasonable prices. It’s the perfect spot for a quick lunch or a late-night snack. The lines can get long during peak hours, but the tacos are well worth the wait.
Sipping on Tequila: More than Just Restaurants
While exploring the Upper West Side’s Mexican flavors, consider that there are ways to celebrate Mexican flavors beyond sit-down restaurants. While the neighborhood isn’t necessarily known for late-night taco trucks, keep an eye out for community events and farmers’ markets. Sometimes, pop-up vendors will appear, offering a delicious, temporary taste of Mexican street food.
For those who enjoy cooking at home, several grocery stores on the Upper West Side offer a wide selection of Mexican ingredients. From dried chilies and spices to fresh tortillas and cheeses, you’ll find everything you need to create your own authentic Mexican dishes. Check out local markets and specialty food stores for the best selection and quality.
Finally, remember the convenience of delivery. Many of the featured restaurants offer delivery services, allowing you to enjoy delicious Mexican food from the comfort of your own home. Whether you’re craving tacos, enchiladas, or a full-blown fiesta, a few clicks can bring the taste of Mexico right to your doorstep. Services like Seamless, Grubhub and UberEats will usually have options.
Navigating the Menu: A Guide to Mexican Delights
Let’s delve into the key components of a satisfying Mexican meal on the Upper West Side.
Tacos
The cornerstone of Mexican cuisine, tacos come in endless variations. Carne asada (grilled steak), al pastor (marinated pork), carnitas (slow-cooked pork), and pollo (chicken) are popular choices. Vegetarian options like grilled vegetables, beans, and cheese are also readily available. For the best carne asada tacos, head to the spot on Broadway. For unique fillings, explore the menus of the family-friendly restaurants on Columbus Avenue, they often experiment with different meats.
Burritos
Similar to tacos, burritos offer a convenient and filling meal. They typically consist of a large flour tortilla wrapped around rice, beans, cheese, your choice of protein, and various toppings. Look for restaurants that offer different types of burritos, such as California burritos (with fries) or breakfast burritos (with eggs and potatoes).
Enchiladas
These rolled tortillas, filled with cheese, meat, or vegetables and covered in sauce, are a true Mexican classic. Green sauce (salsa verde), red sauce (salsa roja), and mole are common enchilada sauces. For creamy, cheesy enchiladas suizas, the family-friendly spot on Columbus Avenue is your best bet.
Beyond the Basics
Don’t overlook other popular Mexican dishes like quesadillas (grilled tortillas filled with cheese and other ingredients), nachos (tortilla chips topped with cheese, beans, and various toppings), guacamole (mashed avocado dip), mole (complex sauce made with chilies and chocolate), and ceviche (seafood marinated in citrus juice). Each restaurant offers its unique take on these classic dishes, so be sure to explore the menu and try something new.
Quench Your Thirst: Mexican Drinks
No Mexican meal is complete without a refreshing beverage. Margaritas are the quintessential Mexican cocktail, made with tequila, lime juice, and orange liqueur. Palomas, made with tequila, grapefruit soda, and lime juice, are another popular choice. Mexican beer, such as Corona, Modelo, and Dos Equis, are always a good option. For a non-alcoholic option, try horchata, a sweet rice milk drink flavored with cinnamon.
Tips for a Delicious Upper West Side Mexican Experience
Reservations: For the sit-down restaurants, reservations are highly recommended, especially during peak hours (Friday and Saturday nights). Check each restaurant’s website or call ahead to make a reservation.
Spice Levels: Don’t be afraid to ask about spice levels! Mexican food can range from mild to very spicy. If you’re sensitive to heat, ask your server for recommendations and request that your food be prepared mild.
Happy Hour: Many restaurants on the Upper West Side offer happy hour deals on Mexican food and drinks. Check their websites or social media pages for the latest specials.
Dietary Restrictions: Most Mexican restaurants can accommodate dietary restrictions. Be sure to inform your server about any allergies or dietary preferences. Vegetarian and gluten-free options are usually readily available.
Your Upper West Side Mexican Adventure Awaits
The Upper West Side’s Mexican food scene may not be as widely known as other culinary hotspots in the city, but it offers a surprising variety of delicious and authentic options. From Oaxacan specialties to street-style tacos, there’s something to satisfy every craving.
So, what are you waiting for? Grab your friends, family, or that special someone, and embark on a culinary adventure to discover your new favorite Mexican spot on the Upper West Side. Explore the featured restaurants, sample the diverse menu options, and share your own experiences.
The Upper West Side’s Mexican food is a vibrant and evolving culinary scene, ready to tantalize your taste buds and transport you to the heart of Mexico. Now get out there and enjoy the fiesta! With flavors that ignite the senses and a warm, welcoming atmosphere, The Upper West Side now has what you have been looking for.
