Introduction
Craving a taste of Mexico right here on the Upper West Side? You’re absolutely in luck! Beyond the iconic museums and picturesque brownstones, this vibrant neighborhood holds a surprisingly diverse and delicious selection of Mexican restaurants. But let’s be honest, finding truly exceptional Mexican cuisine in New York City, especially outside of traditionally Latin areas, can sometimes feel like searching for a hidden treasure. The question on everyone’s mind is: can you really discover authentic and flavorful Mexican fare on the Upper West Side? The answer is a resounding sí! This guide is your passport to exploring the best Upper West Side Mexican food, showcasing a range of flavors, atmospheres, and experiences that will transport your taste buds south of the border. Prepare for a fiesta!
What Makes Mexican Food “Best” on the Upper West Side?
Before diving into specific recommendations, it’s important to define what criteria we’re using to judge the best Mexican food on the Upper West Side. While personal preferences certainly play a role, there are some key elements that separate the good from the truly great.
First, we consider authenticity. This doesn’t necessarily mean a rigid adherence to only the oldest, most traditional recipes. Instead, it means a commitment to representing the diverse regions and flavors of Mexico. From the coastal seafood preparations to the rich, complex moles of Oaxaca, Mexican cuisine is incredibly varied. A truly authentic restaurant will showcase this diversity and use techniques and ingredients that reflect a genuine understanding of Mexican culinary traditions. Freshly made tortillas, for instance, are a hallmark of authenticity and a clear indicator that a restaurant is serious about its craft.
The quality of ingredients is another critical factor. Fresh, locally sourced produce whenever possible, high-quality cuts of meat, and authentic Mexican spices are all essential for creating flavorful and memorable dishes. You can taste the difference when ingredients are carefully selected and handled with respect.
Of course, flavor is paramount. The best Mexican food is a symphony of tastes and textures, a harmonious balance of spices, herbs, and savory elements. The use of chiles to add depth and complexity, the careful layering of flavors in a slow-cooked stew, and the bright, refreshing taste of fresh cilantro and lime are all hallmarks of exceptional Mexican cuisine.
Beyond the food itself, the atmosphere of a restaurant plays a significant role in the overall dining experience. Whether you’re looking for a casual spot to grab a quick taco or a more upscale restaurant for a special occasion, the ambiance should complement the food and create a welcoming and enjoyable environment.
Finally, price is always a consideration. The best restaurants offer a good value for money, providing delicious food and a satisfying experience at a reasonable price point. We’ll highlight options for different budgets, so you can find the perfect spot for any occasion. We will also rely on online customer reviews and reputations, this is important for judging popularity.
Restaurants Serving Up Mexican Flavor
Let’s explore some of the Upper West Side’s top Mexican restaurants. These selections are based on a combination of the criteria outlined above, along with careful consideration of customer reviews and local recommendations.
Casa Mexicana: A Taste of Tradition
Located in the heart of the Upper West Side, Casa Mexicana offers a warm and inviting atmosphere that feels like stepping into a family-run restaurant in Mexico. The decor is colorful and festive, and the staff is friendly and attentive.
But the real star of the show is the food. Casa Mexicana is known for its authentic dishes, prepared with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The mole poblano is a must-try, a complex and flavorful sauce made with over twenty different ingredients, including chiles, spices, and chocolate. It’s rich, savory, and slightly sweet, a true masterpiece of Mexican cuisine.
Another standout dish is the tacos al pastor. Thinly sliced pork, marinated in a blend of spices and pineapple, is cooked on a vertical spit and then shaved onto warm tortillas. The combination of savory pork, sweet pineapple, and spicy salsa is simply irresistible.
Casa Mexicana also boasts an impressive selection of tequilas and mezcals, perfect for pairing with your meal. And their margaritas are made with fresh lime juice and top-shelf tequila. What sets Casa Mexicana apart is its unwavering commitment to authenticity and its warm, welcoming atmosphere. It’s the perfect spot for a casual dinner with friends or a special celebration. Expect to spend around $$ per person. You can find them on Amsterdam Avenue.
Maya’s Modern Mexican: A Contemporary Twist
For a more modern and upscale take on Mexican cuisine, head to Maya’s Modern Mexican. This stylish restaurant features a sleek and contemporary design, with a vibrant bar scene and a sophisticated dining room.
The menu at Maya’s Modern Mexican is innovative and creative, showcasing a range of contemporary interpretations of classic Mexican dishes. The ceviche is a standout, made with fresh seafood, citrus juice, and a variety of flavorful toppings. It’s light, refreshing, and perfect for a warm evening.
The short rib enchiladas are another must-try. Tender, slow-braised short ribs are wrapped in soft corn tortillas and smothered in a rich and savory enchilada sauce. They’re hearty, flavorful, and incredibly satisfying.
Maya’s Modern Mexican also has an extensive cocktail menu, featuring a variety of creative margaritas and other tequila-based drinks. The spicy mango margarita is a popular choice, a perfect balance of sweet, spicy, and tangy flavors. Maya’s Modern Mexican is a great choice for a special occasion or a night out with friends. The prices are around $$$. Located near Central Park West.
El Ranchito Taqueria: A Casual Favorite
For a quick and affordable Mexican fix, look no further than El Ranchito Taqueria. This casual spot is a favorite among locals for its delicious tacos, burritos, and other Mexican staples.
The tacos are the main attraction at El Ranchito Taqueria. They offer a variety of fillings, including carne asada, carnitas, pollo, and vegetables. The tortillas are warm and soft, and the fillings are flavorful and generous.
The burritos are also a popular choice, filled with your choice of meat or vegetables, rice, beans, cheese, and salsa. They’re large, filling, and incredibly satisfying. El Ranchito Taqueria is a great spot for a quick lunch or dinner on the go. The prices are very reasonable, making it a great option for budget-conscious diners. Expect to spend around $ per person. They have several locations along Broadway.
Exploring the Upper West Side’s Taco Scene
Let’s take a closer look at one of the most beloved Mexican dishes: tacos. The Upper West Side boasts a surprising variety of taco options, each with its own unique style and flavor.
At Casa Mexicana, the tacos al pastor are a standout. The marinated pork is cooked to perfection and served with a generous helping of pineapple and salsa. The combination of sweet, savory, and spicy flavors is simply irresistible.
El Ranchito Taqueria offers a more casual taco experience, with a variety of fillings to choose from. The carne asada tacos are a popular choice, featuring tender grilled steak, onions, cilantro, and salsa.
Maya’s Modern Mexican offers a more upscale taco experience, with creative and innovative fillings. Their fish tacos are a standout, featuring crispy battered fish, slaw, and a tangy chipotle aioli.
No matter your preference, you’re sure to find a taco to love on the Upper West Side.
Beyond the Restaurants: A Taste of Mexico at Home
While dining out is a great way to experience Mexican cuisine, you can also enjoy the flavors of Mexico at home. Several local grocery stores carry a wide variety of Mexican ingredients, allowing you to create your own authentic dishes.
Mexican Grocery Stores
If you truly want a taste of mexico, you can find it at one of the many mexican grocery stores located near the subway. They are known to have a range of mexican spices and imported mexican ingredients you can’t find anywhere else.
De Kalb Market Hall
If you want a full immersive experience, you can visit De Kalb Market Hall and sample the range of cuisines while purchasing Mexican ingrediants and spices.
Summing Up the Upper West Side’s Mexican Food Scene
The Upper West Side’s Mexican food scene is a delicious surprise, a hidden gem waiting to be discovered. From authentic family-run restaurants to modern and innovative interpretations of classic dishes, there’s something for everyone. Whether you’re craving a flavorful mole, a crispy taco, or a refreshing margarita, you’re sure to find it on the Upper West Side. Ditch the ordinary and embark on a culinary adventure! Explore the restaurants mentioned in this guide, try something new, and share your own favorite Mexican spots in the comments below. The Upper West Side is ready to transport your taste buds south of the border. The Upper West Side Mexican food scene offers a refreshing change of pace. So, embrace the fiesta and discover the delicious flavors of Mexico right here in your own backyard. Enjoy!
